All-Terrain Tires Talk: Best Picks & User Feedback

Hey everyone! 👋
So, this is my first forum post. I’ve been getting a lot of comments on the site, and I figured it’s time to create a space where we can easily discuss things together, share experiences, and talk tires without all the back-and-forth in the comments section.
Lately, I’ve been thinking about the best all-terrain tires, and after 1 more year of testing, these are now my top picks (a little different from my article on best all terrain tires here).
They make the most sense to me, especially when you factor in their performance, durability, and value for money.
So the first on the list is...

Mickey Thompson Baja Boss A/T

Now I've already disccussed this in my post of AT4w on my site (tiredriver.com), that initially my top choice was the Wildpeak AT3w, as this tire checked almost all boxes, and provided amazing wet traction... The thing is, wet traction is one of the most difficult tasks for off-road tires.

But with AT4w coming in, where Falken focused ore off road performance things changed a lot. So yes I am picking Baja Boss A/T.

I think this is the best all-terrain tire, overall. Why well the tire offers a very nice dry and wet performance (offering shorter braking compared to Toyo AT3, for example) and is the best when it comes to snow traction.

Plus you also get superb durability with 3 ply construction (having denser cords in them, comparatively).
And sidewalls... I think this tire offers the most aggressive sidewall lugs in its category.

And they aren't just for looks, they really perform on all sorts of rugged off-road terrains.

And although the tire is a little noisy (though quieter than tires like Ridge Grappler, and Duratrac), it offers decent road smoothness.
So yes overall, I think its a nice overall pick for folks who do 50 50 on and off road.

Yokohama Geolandar AT G015

Now this tire, I consider the best all-terrain tire for on road oriented A/T category. Its the best I've ever seen/tested when it comes to overall comfort (both road smoothness and noise). And its one of the best in dry and wet conditions, in terms of braking in particular.

Now handling wise, its okay in dry, but it needs some help when roads get slicker where the tire tends to understeer. But its performance is still comparable (only slightly off) to Wildpeak AT Trail.

In terms of winter performance, where BFG Trail Terrain is the king, the G015 offers the similar overall snow handling, even though it stops 6 feet longer in snow braking and, greater, 10 feet longer in ice braking compared to BFG.

But considering the Geolandar G015's price tag and more than okay performance in other key areas including off road, I still consider it a great option.
Now in my blog post, though, the following tire is what I considered as the best on road oriented all terrain tire.

Cooper Discoverer Road+Trail AT

This one’s for the folks who need something a bit more on-road friendly, and to be honest you are good with both (this and G015) here. I mean if you're stuck between those two, get the G015 for comfort, and get Road Trail if you want more traction on road.

Once thing I really like about this tire though is its much better sidewall lugs especially compared to others in its category. This makes it a very good option overall indeed.

General Grabber ATX

If longevity is what you're after, the General Grabber ATX is a strong contender. The tread life is impressive, and it performs well in snow. However, wet traction could be better as it starts to wear down.

BF Goodrich KO3

The KO3 is a game changer, especially for wet traction. Its improved siping and aqua channels make it a top performer in rainy conditions, which is a big improvement over the KO2.

Firestone Destination AT2

When it comes to fuel economy, the Firestone Destination AT2 is the most efficient all-terrain tire I’ve tested.
It’s also pretty decent in wet conditions but lacks a bit in dry traction.

Continental Terrain Contact A/T

For those looking for the quietest ride and best on-road handling, the Continental Terrain Contact A/T is hard to beat.
However, it’s not as strong in muddy off-road conditions.

Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac RT

If you’re serious about muddy terrains, the Goodyear DuraTrac RT is the best pick. Its mud-ejecting design and aggressive lugs make it a powerhouse in challenging off-road environments.

Kenda Klever AT2

This one’s a budget-friendly choice, offering great value for its price. It’s not ideal for heavy off-road use, but it performs well in rocky terrains and snowy conditions.

Toyo Open Country AT3

Last on my list, but still solid, is the Toyo Open Country AT3. It’s a well-rounded tire with good dry traction and noise reduction, but it could perform better in wet conditions and off-road durability.
But considering its price, its a nice all rounder performer and deserves to be here.

So there you have it—my personal picks for the best all-terrain tires as off now. If anything changes I would definitely let you guys know.
So what's your personal list of top/best all terrain tires, and have you tried any of these above? I’d love to hear your thoughts.